This article examines the potential for conditional quashing orders as a new form of relief in judicial review proceedings. The analysis considers whether current remedial options are sufficient or whether reform is needed. Traditional quashing orders operate as binary remedies - either the decision stands or it is struck down. This can create difficulties where the underlying decision-making process has flaws but the outcome may still be correct. Conditional quashing orders would allow courts to suspend the effect of quashing while giving public bodies an opportunity to remedy procedural defects. This could reduce the need for complete re-determination while ensuring proper process is followed. The article examines comparative approaches from other jurisdictions, including Australia and Canada, where similar remedies have been developed. The experience suggests that conditional remedies can provide more flexible and proportionate responses to administrative law failures. However, implementation would require careful consideration of timing, conditions, and the relationship with other remedies. The article concludes that while conditional quashing orders could improve judicial review, their introduction would require legislative reform.
Accessible at: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/14737795231225478.