Proving and Averring Foreign Law in Scots Private International Law: A Hindrance to Efficiency?

2018-09-30By Dr Kane Abry
Retour aux actualités

This paper examines the procedural requirements for proving foreign law in Scottish courts and considers whether current rules create unnecessary barriers to effective dispute resolution. Scots private international law requires parties to prove foreign law as a matter of fact rather than law. This creates significant procedural hurdles and can lead to increased costs and delays in international litigation. The study compares the Scottish approach with other common law jurisdictions, revealing significant variations in how foreign law is treated procedurally. Some jurisdictions have adopted more flexible approaches that reduce the burden on parties. The research examines specific cases where the requirement to prove foreign law has created difficulties, including commercial disputes and family law matters. The analysis reveals how procedural requirements can sometimes override substantive justice considerations. The paper considers potential reforms, including judicial notice of foreign law in certain circumstances and improved mechanisms for obtaining expert evidence. The aim is to maintain accuracy while improving efficiency. The conclusion suggests that while the current approach has historical justification, modern practice requires more flexible procedures that can accommodate the realities of international legal practice.

Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4393177.

About the author

Dr Kane Abry

Practice areas

Share this article