“Should student unions, like universities, be prevented by law from non-platforming speakers?” [as enacted, but not brought into force, by the Academic Freedom (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023]
This opinion examines whether student unions, like universities, should be legally constrained from “non-platforming” speakers, as contemplated by the Academic Freedom (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023. While freedom of expression under Article 10 ECHR is conventionally framed as a protection against state interference and does not confer a general right to be provided with a platform by private bodies, the opinion argues that this doctrinal position does not exhaust the normative question. Universities and student unions occupy a distinctive institutional role as gatekeepers to a key public sphere central to democratic education, intellectual contestation, and the formation of civic competence. Their decisions about access to platforms therefore have disproportionate effects on public deliberation. The opinion contends that Parliament may legitimately impose speech-protective duties on such bodies without treating them as public authorities for all purposes. It rejects an absolute prohibition on non-platforming and instead proposes a structured, Article 10–inspired framework. Lawful speech should benefit from a presumption of access, with the burden on institutions to justify refusal. Non-platforming should be permissible only where proposed speech is unlawful, constitutes an abuse of rights akin to proselytism of hatred, or poses a demonstrable, evidence-based risk to public order or the rights of others that cannot be mitigated by less restrictive means. Robust procedural safeguards and reasoned decision-making are essential to prevent ideological capture and the “heckler’s veto.” The opinion concludes that such a calibrated legal regime best preserves freedom of expression and academic freedom while recognising the legitimate limits of institutional tolerance.